Business Advice15 min

Tackling Construction Labor Shortages with Simplified Building Methods

For developers, builders and contractors the labor shortage is significant: The construction industry lost 1,5 million jobs during the recession. Today, only about half of those jobs have been filled. The diminished workforce helps explain the project delays and rising costs associated with home construction today, according to Robert Dietz, chief economist of the National Association of Home Builders.

"We have a labor shortage," Dietz says. "It has been the top business challenge for the last three years and will likely continue to be so."

You've probably seen the effects of the shortage firsthand. It's a difficult situation with no easy answers. For example, one worrisome trend is the rising average age of construction workers, now inching up towards the mid-40s. An aging workforce means fewer young people are entering the trades.

To address the labor and experience shortfall, the industry has responded in a variety of ways, from higher wages to aggressive worker training initiatives.

This installment of Code Counts examines one industry response: Simplifying a common building practice with a code-compliant, worker-friendly alternative.

Partition walls

In structures with fire walls and multifamily stairwell applications, load-bearing partition walls are major design elements that often require fire- and acoustic-rated wall assemblies, as well as a floor-to-wall connection details that maintain the continuity of the fire rating.

Traditional shaft wall construction is a comparatively complex construction process. Fire tape, H-studs, C-channels, breakaway clips and two layers of fire-rated gypsum are typical construction components. Many framers view shaft walls as difficult to build and often charge more per square foot to assemble them, according to Wayne Baker, chief operating officer of Fleming Homes of Raleigh, N.C.

UL BXUV.U350 Assembly

Another wall design option allows for faster, simpler installs using a different approach. For this reason, some architects, homebuilders and framing contractors have turned to wall assemblies that eliminate shaft liner type gypsum and the associated hardware. A lighter-weight assembly can then be platform-built (horizontally), an easier way for framers to build, requiring less stooping and reaching. Once the assembly is finished, the framing crew tilts it up vertically and secures it to the building framework.

A UL-approved assembly, UL BXUV.U350, is being specified more frequently for interior, load-bearing walls separating living units. The U350 wall represents a lighter, more streamlined wall assembly option for town home and multi-family applications requiring a two-hour rated continuous separation wall.

Supporting U350 construction is a type of code-compliant oriented strand board (OSB) panel sheathing, like LP® FlameBlock®. The weight of the assembly is reduced by utilizing the fire-resistant OSB in combination with standard, Type X gypsum to reduce the overall amount of gypsum, as compared to a typical shaft liner separation wall (a single 10-foot by 2-foot by 1-inch thick drywall panel weighs just over 50 pounds). Code compliance of the sheathing is supported by an International Code Council code report and certified test results:

  • ICC-ES evaluated under report number ESR-1365
  • Structural design values and PS-2 compliance evaluated under Pei Report PER_0613
  • Meets extended ASTM E84 (UL723) extended burn test outlined in ICC-ES acceptance criteria AC264, Section 4,1
  • Exposure 1 classification (withstand moisture exposure during construction delays)

The panel also offers full standard structural load/span and shear values for each thickness category. It installs with standard tools, methods and fasteners.

Labor Implications

UL U350 wall assemblies that utilize the fire-resistant OSB panels represent a more builder-friendly construction solution. "It doesn't require a carpenter's level of ability or years of installation experience to build U350 wall assemblies," observes Joe Noernberg, an account manager with building products manufacturer LP Corporation.

For example, the U350 assembly with OSB sheathing recently supported the construction of a townhouse community for Habitat for Humanity. The volunteer, largely inexperienced workforce were able to build U350 assemblies "… probably a month or two faster than a shaft wall assembly," says Sean Allen, director of construction and real estate for the local Habitat for Humanity chapter. This version of the U350 assembly eliminates the need for a 1-inch-thick gypsum panel and associated hardware, speeding construction. Local code officials had no problem approving the UL-listed assembly.

Noernberg sees a lighter-weight party wall option as a benefit for a labor-challenged construction industry. "The labor shortage is a big issue in the Denver market. It's really slowing the pace of construction," Noernberg says. "We're also losing a lot of experienced framers and carpenters to retirement. That's a lot of know-how walking out the door. Anything you can do to help speed up and simplify construction helps."

Summary

The response to the construction industry's labor shortages must take many forms. One expected outcome is an increased reliance on building material innovation to help offset a diminished labor force and experience base. Code officials should anticipate that architects and homebuilders might in the future specify code-compliant alternative construction methods to help meet market demand without compromising structural quality, safety and performance.

To learn more, visit ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-1365.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of LP and do not necessarily reflect those of the International Code Council, or Hanley Wood.

Continue Reading
Industry Trends5 min

Solutions for the Starter Home Shortage

The supply of modestly priced starter homes continues to drop nationwide. A recent report by Realtor.com found that the number of homes priced above 750 000 $ grew 11 percent last year, while the number of starter homes priced under 200 000 $ fell by 8 percent.

Continue Reading
News & Stories6 min
The What’s & Why’s of the LP® SmartSide® 5/50 Limited Warranty

Any building professional will tell you that the quality of a building material is only as good as its warranty. This is why LP Building Solutions created an industry-leading limited warranty for our line of LP® SmartSide® siding products. One that aims to ensure peace-of-mind for builders and homeowners.

Business Advice6 min
Why It’s Important To “Respect the Spec”

While it's perfectly alright for a jazz musician to improvise, that approach doesn't always work as well in homebuilding. Architects, specifiers, engineers and product reps spend many hours collaboratively choosing the right materials for each job - and an abrupt substitution to save a few dollars can ironically be very costly in terms of callbacks, design underperformance and even code violations. "Ideally, all parties involved - the architect, builder and developer - have reviewed the spec before it's final and have agreed on all the products being used," says Karen Alves, LP Brand Marketing Associate. "That's because finding an 'equivalent' for siding or fire-rated sheathing involves not just the substrate but the codes that the product meets as well."

Business Advice4 min
Siding That’s a Cut Above

Siding installers use many different brands of circular saws, but their preferred saw may not be as important as the siding material they are cutting with it. Some builders can sometimes be a bit removed from the importance placed on saw choice and would probably rely on their subcontractors choice, like Brent Taylor. "I don't have much of an opinion on that because I use subcontracted labor," says Brent Taylor, owner of O.C. Taylor in Raleigh, North Carolina, who was featured in an episode of Designing Spaces on Lifetime Network renovating a century-old house using LP® SmartSide® Trim & Siding.